Career Advancement, Leadership and Promotion: The Mid-Career GPS Podcast
You’re doing great work. So why are you still being overlooked for promotions, leadership opportunities, or your next career move?
The Mid-Career GPS Podcast helps mid-career professionals build the visibility, influence, and career strategy to move forward. If you’re a manager, senior manager, or director who feels stuck, undervalued, or uncertain about what’s next, you’re in the right place.
I’m John Neral, a leadership and career coach. Each week, I share practical strategies and candid conversations to help you communicate your value, strengthen your leadership presence, and make more confident career decisions.
You’ll learn how to position yourself for promotion, navigate difficult workplace conversations, build strategic relationships, and lead with greater impact.
We’ll also tackle job search strategy, interviewing, and career transitions when your next step means moving to a new organization.
At the heart of this podcast are my SHOW UP strategies, helping you take an active role in your career instead of waiting for someone else to recognize your potential.
With more than 360 episodes, you’ll find guidance for the challenges and opportunities that come with this stage of your career.
Subscribe to The Mid-Career GPS Podcast and start building a clearer path to what’s next.
Explore coaching and free career resources at https://johnneral.com.
Career Advancement, Leadership and Promotion: The Mid-Career GPS Podcast
369: The Iced Coffee Interview Tip Debate
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
If you’re searching for a new job at mid-career, you may be wondering what it takes to stand out in an interview. Does bringing your interviewer an iced coffee show thoughtfulness, or does it raise questions about your professional judgment?
In this episode of The Mid-Career GPS Podcast, I unpack the viral “iced coffee interview” debate and explain why a seemingly thoughtful gesture can create an uncomfortable first impression.
When you’re frustrated with your career or navigating a competitive job search, I understand the temptation to try something different. But I want your interviewer to remember your leadership, experience, and the value you bring. A drink or gift can pull attention away from the conversation you worked hard to prepare for.
I explore how bringing coffee to an interviewer can introduce safety concerns, suggest that you’re trying to win favor, or conflict with an organization’s gift policies. I also share a fruit basket story from a school district hiring process that illustrates how good intentions can raise concerns about a candidate’s judgment.
Then, I focus on practical job interview tips for mid-career professionals who want to communicate their strengths and find a role where they can lead more impactfully. From telling relevant stories to reading the room, I explain how to build rapport while keeping the focus on your qualifications.
In this episode, I cover:
- Why bringing coffee or a gift to your interviewer can create unnecessary distractions.
- How industry expectations and workplace policies can affect interview etiquette.
- What a school district hiring experience taught me about intentions and professional judgment.
- How to communicate your accomplishments and connect your experience to the organization’s needs.
- Why I recommend accepting water when it’s offered and minimizing opportunities for spills.
- How to assess the room before using humor or taking a more casual approach.
- Why I believe thoughtful preparation and self-awareness make a stronger impression than a memorable gesture.
If you’re preparing for a job interview, pursuing a promotion, or exploring a career change, I want to help you show up with confidence and clarity. Your interview is also an opportunity to assess whether the organization supports the kind of work, leadership, and career growth you want.
Apply for private leadership and career coaching at https://www.johnneral.com/workwithme
Listen to this episode before your next interview. I’ll help you focus on what you want decision-makers to remember: how you think, how you lead, and how you can help their organization succeed.
For more resources on job search, promotion, and career clarity, visit johnneral.com.
Follow The Mid-Career GPS Podcast and share the episode with someone navigating their next career move.
If this episode resonated with you and you want more support in how you SHOW UP for your career and life, there are two ways we can work together.
If you would like to learn more about how I can help you as your leadership and career coach, visit https://www.johnneral.com/workwithme.
Get John's free weekly leadership and career newsletter at https://www.johnneral.com/the-mid-career-gps-newsletter
Other ways we can connect:
- Connect with John on LinkedIn here.
- Get John's books on Amazon here.
- Follow John on Instagram @johnneralcoaching.
- Subscribe to John's YouTube Channel here.
Please leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts here.
This podcast is listed in Feedspot's Top 90 Best Executive Career Podcasts.
https://podcast.feedspot.com/executive_career_podcasts/
Welcome And Who This Is For
John NeralHello, my friends, and welcome to the Mid-Career GPS Podcast. I'm your host, John Narrell. This is the show for mid-career professionals who feel stuck, undervalued, or unsure what's next, and know that doing more isn't the answer. Here we focus on how you show up, and that means how you make clear decisions, build influence, and take control of your career. Let's get started.
The Iced Coffee Interview Trend
John NeralAll right, grab your favorite beverage of choice, whatever you want to drink while you're listening to this podcast episode, and perhaps it is an iced coffee. But we're going to talk about iced coffee today and whether or not it is appropriate for you as a mid-career professional to bring an iced coffee to the person who's interviewing you. Now, if you've been following this trend on social media, you've heard the debate and listened to the discussions and read the comments, everybody's got an interesting take on it. But for you as the mid-career professional who perhaps is interviewing for a position right now and you want to stand out and you want to get noticed, you might be thinking this could be the thing that will make you more memorable and make you stand out. Here's what I want to challenge Is it going to make you memorable and help you stand out in the way you ultimately want? Now, I understand that different industries have different expectations or protocols. Different companies may be a little bit more relaxed in their interview process, and they may actually welcome something like this or think this is a very nice gesture. What I want you to get really clear on today is what are your thoughts about potentially bringing the interviewer a drink, an iced coffee, a hot coffee, a hot tea, whatever it is. I have heard people say, I've read comments online saying, oh, I would call the organization and talk to their assistant and get a heads up about what they like to drink. And then I would go ahead and bring it to them.
Why It Can Backfire Fast
John NeralHere's where I believe this could potentially backfire for you. And just to be really clear, I don't recommend doing this. I think this is an awful move to make in an interview. Here's my number one reason. If I'm the interviewer and you walk into my office and you say, Oh, look, I brought you an iced coffee, or I called your assistant and found out what your favorite beverage is, and I brought this to you. I don't know you. Why would I accept a drink from a total stranger? Now, I might be a little skeptical, I might be a little paranoid, I might be a little too rigid, but I'm not gonna do it. I'm not gonna take a sip out of that drink because you just brought it to me. Thank you for the gesture. I'm gonna put it off to the side, and I'm never gonna touch it during the interview, and it's gonna drive you nuts wondering why I'm not taking a sip of that drink. I just don't. I don't accept drinks from people whom I don't know unless it's in a closed container. Okay, that's one. Secondly, are you trying to bribe me? I mean, in the end, this could be a very well-intentioned gesture on your part to do something like that. But are you sucking up a little bit? Are you trying to get ahead? Are you trying to make this really, really good impression that you think by bringing me an iced coffee is going to help me overlook a potential weakness or a gap on your resume or something? Like, what's the motivation behind it? So you could dramatically shift the energy in the interview by doing something like that. Now, if it's an industry, if it's an organization where something like that is looked favorably upon, you may choose to go ahead and do that. And it might be totally okay. You have to understand where you're interviewing. My take is in general, I think this is a really bad move.
Gift Rules And The Fruit Basket Story
John NeralI remember working in one organization. I was working for a school district at the time, and it was a very competitive process for interviewing for teachers. And I happened to be in the board office. We were getting ready to welcome some candidates in for uh an interview. And a delivery person came in with this huge fruit basket and a resume attached to it. And we couldn't accept the delivery. We couldn't accept the delivery because, as a government employee, we were not allowed to accept gifts over $25. And it was very clear that this fruit basket was worth way more than $25. What do you think the impression was for that candidate? The impression was we can't accept this. And you didn't know we couldn't accept it. So already this person has created an impression or an experience that while may have been very well intended, didn't land well.
Safer Ways To Make An Impression
John NeralWhen you go in for an interview, yes, your role is to impress. You are impressing them with your skills, your talents, your ability to tell a story, your self-awareness, your technical expertise, your leadership values, and why you believe you are the best candidate to fill that role at this particular time, because listen very carefully to me here, because of how you are going to help them. You don't need an iced coffee to help you do that. Now, I do firmly believe that if you walk into an interview and they say, Would you like a bottle of water? You accept it is an opportunity for you to be gracious. Unless if you've already brought your own water, you might say, I already have some water with me. Thank you very much. Maybe you keep it in your bag, you keep it in your purse, whatever that might be. Okay. I am someone who tends to get uh a very dry mouth when he speaks a lot. So whenever I'm speaking on stage or even as I'm doing this podcast, I keep a bottle of water nearby. I will always have an opportunity to stay hydrated, but I will always thank them or accept the bottle of water because that's an opportunity to accept something you're giving me in a very safe environment. Now, could you do that and be like, hey, I have an extra bottle of water? Do you want that? Maybe, maybe that's something you do. But an open container of iced coffee, it definitely got a lot of traction online. And what I'm happy about it is it brought up this whole idea about how we interview and how we stand out in a crowded job market. But if you're trying to make an impression, be really clear and clean about the impression you're trying to make. So when I was interviewing and I coach my clients on this as well, water is always a safe bet. If you bring a coffee or a tea or a soda and you're nervous and you risk spilling it, and now you've spilled it on your outfit, your shirt, your tie, your dress, whatever that might be, did you bring an extra outfit? Could you change at some point? Because walking into an interview with a stained attire is not gonna look good. Whenever I interviewed in an organization where I had to wear a suit and tie, I always packed an additional tie in my bag just in case. Right? I was somebody who looked at a lot of different options or scenarios and in what might be.
Reading The Room With Humor
John NeralI I interviewed at one place for a uh a leadership executive type role, and the gentleman who was interviewing me, who sat across from me at the conference table, unintentionally had his shirt button opened. Um, I don't know how he missed it, but it was right at his belly button. And so every time he spoke and the way he sat and the tie was off to the side, it was during the summer, so we didn't have our jackets on, but it looked like his belly button was talking to me. And I called it out in the interview, and he was so unnerved and upset with me about it. I knew at that point there was no way I was gonna get the job. I like I even laughed at one point and I said, in all due respect, sir, would you mind buttoning the button on your shirt? Because it looks like your belly button is talking to me. That did not go over well. I realized then that my bluntness, my sense of humor was not appropriate and not gonna work well in that organization. So the impression I made was not a good one. We have to know the environment in which we are playing. And we have to show up in a way that is authentic and true to ourselves.
Better Gestures After You’re Hired
John NeralLook, if you want to do a nice gesture for the person who's interviewing, there's lots of things you could do once you get the job. You could take them out to lunch. You could buy them the iced coffee at that point. You could even joke with them and say, hey, now that I'm here, I'd love to take you out for an iced coffee. I thought about bringing it to the interview, but uh I just wasn't gonna do that. You could you could make a joke of it in some way, but uh it this is an opportunity for you to get really clear and clean about your thoughts, about why it would be appropriate or inappropriate to do something like that. My take again is I wouldn't do it. It's not something I would welcome if I was an interviewer, and it's not something I would ever do as a candidate because my impression that I want to make is solely going to be anchored in here's how I am going to help you by hiring me into this role based on my skills, talents, and expertise. And I don't need to bring you an iced coffee to get a leg up on my competition or do something quote unquote nice for you as a gesture. When I don't even know if you drink iced coffee and I don't even know if you would accept it. So let me take the unknown out. Let me take the variable out of the equation and let me focus on what I can control and what I have command over. And that is how I show up and how I tell my story.
Weigh In And Keep The Conversation Going
John NeralI'm curious, what do you think? What do you think about the whole iced coffee debate? So feel free to weigh in wherever you see this post on social media, be it LinkedIn, Facebook, or Instagram at Johnnarrell Coaching, LinkedIn at Johnnarrell. And if you are not part of my email newsletter community, I want you to join. It's a free email newsletter. You can find it all at my website, johnnarrell.com, J-O-H-N, N-E-R-A-L. The podcast is one part of the conversation. The other part of the conversation each week happens in my free email newsletter community. And I'd love to have you come on over and be a part of it. So until next time, my friends, remember this. You will build your mid-career GPS one mile or one step at a time. And how you show up matters. Make it a great rest of your day. If you enjoyed this episode, don't keep it to yourself. Kindly share it with someone who needs it. And if you're tired of feeling stuck, overlooked, or underutilized in your career, go to my website, johnner.com to get started. There you'll find free resources, ways to work with me, and details about the Show Up Leadership Lab, my signature membership for mid-career professionals who want to lead better, get noticed, and elevate their career. All the links are in the show notes. You can grab what you need right there. Feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn. And if you're getting value from the show, take 30 seconds to leave a rating and review on your favorite podcast platform. Remember, how you show up matters, and I'll see you next time.